The following Op-Ed was written by Joe Mirabella. Joe Mirabella is a volunteer for Join the Impact as the Washington State Community Organizer. Mirabella is a full time writer and content developer. He is engaged to marry his partner of 5 1/2 years in their home state of Iowa.
Last night President Obama addressed the nation about an issue that is important to all Americans. Regardless of any other defining trait or political agenda, our mutual humanity unites us under one common umbrella; we will all at one point in our lives require medical attention. Anyone who has experienced a serious or debilitating medical condition understands that our current system is overwhelmingly flawed. Even those of us who have had only minor medical problems understand all to well how quickly medical bills can overwhelm us even if we have insurance. Our country is blessed with some of the best medical minds in the world, and yet access is rationed based on economic and social status. Modern societies should care for the weakest among them. The United State’s is fully capable of fulfilling its fundamental promise in the Declaration of Independence:
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
Elemental in the pursuit of happiness in our modern society must be access to health care services. Like so many progressive citizens I am dismayed that the debate about one of the most important institutions in our nation was hijacked by a few unstable individuals. It is vitally important that the President knows he has the support of the progressive community as he continues this important debate. There are currently 5 bills making their way through congress (3 in the house, 2 in the Senate) and we must monitor all of them to make sure the town criers do not intimidate our elected officials from producing a quality and fair bill.
Join the Impact’s mission is to continue the conversation about LGBT citizens and our desire to be treated equally under the law in all 50 states in all matters of civil law. Health care reform fits within that mission. It is vital that the progressive LGBT community insists our families are included in the final legislation. We stand in solidarity with our brothers and sisters who do not have basic hospital visitation rights when the person they spend a lifetime with becomes ill. We understand that people die alone in hospitals while separated from their families because of their sexual orientation. We hope that as we stand with the President today on his goal for a health care bill (and his original goal for a public option), that he understands that health care reform is not just about insurance or about money, but about families who in times of crisis should not be separated from each other under any circumstance. When “family” is defined in the health care legislation the LGBT community must be included. Furthermore, Domestic partners and same sex married couples must be able to share health benefits without the current federal income tax burden on their families. Heterosexual families are not taxed on their shared benefits.
We can not forget our transgender friends and family whose needs are almost always left on the cutting room floor. It is all too common for transgender citizens to be denied health care simply because of who they are. Hospitals refuse their admittance, doctors refuse their care, and health insurance policies explicitly deny so-called “transgender care”. We request a strong public option that does not discriminate based on sexual orientation, gender identity, or gender expression. A public option is particularly important for our transgender community members because they are fired without recourse and regularly denied work altogether. Most health insurance policies are provided by employers so if citizens can not find work they need a public option.
We understand the political significance of the health care reform bill. Conservatives will stop at nothing to smear progressive attempts to reform. We would like to request that as you construct your spin job you leave our families out of it. It will be easy for you to scare people by presenting our families and our issues. You are well practiced. There have already been attempts to scare people away from health care reform because of our inclusion in some drafts. Instead of creating even more fear about our community it would serve us all if you instead debated the structural content of the bills on a broader honest landscape. And if the conservatives remain steadfast in bullying the LGBT community, I hope the progressive community embraces our humanity and refuses not buckle under the pressure. No human should be left behind in what could be the most monumental health care reform bill of this century. The time for outlandish lies from the right is over — the time for swift action from progressives is now.
4 Responses
Fascinating. But remember: not all GLBTs, including those committed to same-sex rights are progressive! I do not support the health care reform plan as articulated by the Democratic Party and other progressives, and I am not ashamed of my position.
It’s not so much that I oppose health care reform so much as I think President Obama and the Democratic Congress do not know what they are doing. I’d like a nice reform bill to pass, but they haven’t sufficiently addressed people’s legitimate concerns.
All GLBT persons will be impacted by this legislation in the form of the resulting higher deficit. Seniors among GLBTs will be at risk of reduced coverage and other doomsday scenarios should our health care system disastrously collapse under the weight of increased coverage without 1) the money to pay for it or 2) an increase in the number of doctors and hospitals to continue to provide adequate coverage for more people. I do not accept for a moment the proposition that the opponents of the progressives’ health care reform are spreading lies and fearmongering. President Obama’s speech addressed some of the weaknesses of the current health care reform bills, but not all of them.
I see no compelling reason to link the struggle for health care reform and the struggle for civil rights. They are separate political issues. It would be far more productive to argue (as some have) that now is the time to demand full GLBT rights regardless of the political climate that considers other issues as being more urgent. Unfortunately those of us who are politically aware or active have to prioritize. But saying that progressive GLBTs should support health care reform is implcitily saying we should prioritize health care reform over gay rights. Which, however much that may actually be true, isn’t something GLBTs should be admitting.
Posted on September 13th, 2009 at 1:27 pm
Jorge,
I hear what you are saying, but I think you missed my point. I am not arguing that we should abandon our push for full equality now and focus on health care, I’m arguing that the LGBT community should be able to balance several issues. Health care is on the minds of congress members right now. We must join the conversation or shut up when we are upset with the results of the bill. There are 5 bills on the table right now and we must make sure LGBT citizens are represented in the final bill. If you are unhappy with the contents of the legislation then now is the time to offer concrete solutions because a bill is on the way. One thing is clear, without addressing the issues I brought up, the LGBT community is paying a far higher cost for health care than our heterosexual friends and family. That is a civil rights injustice that must be resolved.
Posted on September 14th, 2009 at 3:15 pm
I’m happy to argue that we should focus 100% for the next few weeks on healthcare reform. It’s the most important legislation for the LGBT community ever. If you want to help the least of those among us pushing for a robust public option is going to help a lot more than hate crimes laws would. This is not a political issue, this is about who you stand with - big corporations who profit from our community being sick, or science and compassion. LGBTQ people face more hurdles in obtaining affordable, ,quality healthcare. It is an absolute shame that none of the most powerful gay rights organizations have taken a strong stand on healthcare.
Posted on October 26th, 2009 at 3:04 am
VICTORY VICTORY VICTORY!!!!!!!!!!! The people of Mairne have let their voice be heard. No more activist judges and corrupt politicians. We the people have to take back our voice in this society and not leave it to the PC social engineers. Gays have never won a ballot measure when the people vote on it. You don’t have the support that you think you have. The tail does not wag the dog. You lost and seem to keep losing. GET OVER IT.
Posted on November 4th, 2009 at 9:22 am
Add A Comment